Change of legal status of sex work in Ukraine: public opinion, opinion of sex workers (sociological perspective)

25
3
Article(UKR)(.pdf)
Article(ENG)(.pdf)

The concepts of “decriminalization” and “legalization” of sex work are defined. Based on a sociological study, the attitudes of the Ukrainian public and sex workers to the potential change in the legal status of sex services in Ukraine is characterized. Authors analyse the public attitude toward the concepts and phenomena of “sex work” and “sex workers”, level of awareness of the population and sex workers about the current legislation in the scope of sex work regulation in Ukraine and the attitude to it, opinions on potential conditions of decriminalization and expected changes as a result of changes in the sex work legal status, level of interest of sex workers in the fact of decriminalization and legalization and their readiness for possible changes. These studies show an utterly predictable contrast between the attitudes, desires and expectations regarding potential changes in the legal status of sex work in Ukraine of the average Ukrainian and a sex worker – from disinclination and rejection of such changes by the first to the unreadiness and possible radiant hopes of the latter. Thus, 51% of Ukrainians oppose the revocation of penalty for the voluntary provision of paid sex services, while 93% of sex workers are interested in the revocation of such penalty. Modelling the situation where the penalty for sex work is revoked, the potential improvements suggested by sex workers are the following: safer working conditions and reduced risks of violence – 74%; the possibility of legal protection from the police – 67%, in court and prosecutor’s office – 64%; reduction of stigma at the level of society – 58%, at the level of self-esteem – 53%; expected reduction in health risks, including HIV/STIs – 49%. The appropriateness to form a public attitude to sex work as a type of entrepreneurial activity, which should be regulated by labour, civil, economic, financial and other branches of law, and to sex workers as those who are entitled to refuse (a client, employer, profession in general), appropriate working conditions and trade union or judicial protection, anonymity, social guarantees and pensions, self-organization, etc. are proved.

  1. Hema, M. (2018). Sex business in Ukraine: is decriminalization necessary? iPress.ua. URL: https://ipress.ua/articles/seksbiznes_v_ukraini_chy_potribna_dekryminalizatsiya_250051.html [in Ukrainian]

  2. Zaitseva, O. (2018). The Swedish model of combating prostitution: counteraction, but not comfortisation. Gender in details. URL: https://genderindetail.org.ua/season-topic/seksualnist/shvedska-model-borotbi-z-prostitutsieyu-protidiya-a-ne-komfortizatsiya-134359.html [in Ukrainian]

  3. Rachok, D. (2018). Sex work and all: principles and implementation of legalization and decriminalization. Gender in details. URL: https://genderindetail.org.ua/season-topic/seksualnist/sex-robota-i-vsi-vsi-vsi-printsipi-ta-vtilennya-legalizatsii-i-dekriminalizatsii-134370.html [in Ukrainian]

  4. Prostitution in Ukraine: a business that does not seem to exist. (2018). Delo.ua. URL: https://delo.ua/econonomyandpoliticsinukraine/prostitucija-v-ukraine-biznes-kotorogo-kak-by-net-339150/ [in Russian]

  5. Legalize or ban? Why no country in the world can legally solve the problem of prostitution. (2019). URL: https://knife.media/world-prostitution-laws/ [in Russian]

  6. Gabrelyan, A. (2018). Validity of legalization of prostitution in Ukraine: arguments “for”. Suchasni pytannia ekonomiky i prava – Modern Issues of Economics and Law, 2, 135-143. URL: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Spep_2018_2_19 [in Ukrainian]

  7. Muraviov, O., Milovanov, T., Talavera, O. (2015). Legalization of prostitution in Ukraine: to be or not to be. Ukrainska pravda. URL: https://www.pravda.com.ua/articles/2015/10/21/7085619/

  8. Balakireva, O., Bondar, T., Galustian, Yu., Haniukov, O.A. (2001). Sex business in Ukraine: an attempt at social analysis. Kyiv: State Institute for Family and Youth [in Ukrainian]

  9. Yaremenko, O.O., Artiukh, O.P., Balakireva, O.M., Bondar, T.V., Varban, M.Yu. (2003). Monitoring of the sex workers’ behaviour. Kyiv: Ukrainian Institute for Social Research [in Ukrainian]

  10. Balakireva, O.M., Bondar, T.V., Sereda, Yu.V. (2008). Monitoring behavior of female commercial sex workers as a component of the second generation epidemiological survey. Kyiv: ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://aph.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Zvit_ZKS.pdf [in Ukrainian]

  11. Issues of sex business in the context of public health. (2009). Kiev: AIDS Foundation East-West. URL: https://www.aidsactioneurope.org/sites/default/files/1091-0_0.pdf [in Russian]

  12. Artiukh, O.P., Balakireva, O.M., Bochkova, L.V., Halych, Yu.P., Galustian, Yu.M., Dikova-Favorska, D.M., Zlobina, O.H., Levchuk, N.M., Liutyi, V.P., Martsynovska, V.A., Mykytiuk, T.P., Morozov, V.F., Petrovskyi, O.M., Shamota, T.S., Yaremenko, O.O. (2005). Monitoring behavior of female commercial sex workers as a component of the second generation epidemiological survey. Kyiv: ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://aph.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/csw.pdf [in Ukrainian]

  13. Behavioural monitoring and HIV infection prevalence among female sex workers as a component of second generation surveillance: analytical report based on results of 2009 survey among FSW. (2010). Kyiv: ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://publichealth.org.ua/storage/IOM_for%20NGO/02%20Harm%20Reduction/CSW_report_2010.pdf [in Ukrainian]

  14. Demchenko, I., Pyvovarova, N., Pliushch, A., Artiukh, O., Kostiuchok, M., Belonosova, N., Varban, M., Matiiash, O. (2012). Investigating causes influencing manifestations of violence against female sex workers (FSW) as a factor of increased risk of exposure to HIV. Kyiv: Analytical Center “Socioconsulting”, ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: https://www.belaids.net/uploads/docs/2014/viol_full_ru.pdf [in Russian]

  15. Study of knowledge about HIV/AIDS/STI, attitude to problems and behavioral practices of FSW’s clients. (2013). Kyiv: Analytical Center “Socioconsulting”, ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://aph.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/resume-klients-rus.pdf [in Russian]

  16. Varban, M., Shulha, L., Demchenko, I., Belonosova, N. (2014). The life of people vulnerable to HIV: injecting drug users, sex workers, men who have sex with men. Kiev: ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://sociocon.org/files/publications/165.pdf [in Russian]

  17. Varban, M., Dovbakh, A., Karelin, M., Kiselev, V., Semena, E. Harm Reduction Community Centres for Groups Vulnerable to HIV: Experience, Practice. Perspectives. Kyiv: ICF “International HIV/AIDS Alliance in Ukraine”. URL: http://aph.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/communitycentres.pdf [in Russian]

  18. Survey among Ukrainian sex workers on human rights violations by law enforcement officers (2015, 2016, 2017). URL: https://issuu.com/natashadorofeyeva/docs/analiz_oprosa_sexswork-2017.docx [in Russian]

  19. Demchenko, I., Bulygina, N., Pivovarova, N., Artiukh, O., Yaremchuk, M., Dorofeeva, N., Isaeva, N. (2019). Decriminalization of sex work in Ukraine: analysis of public opinion, assessment of obstacles and opportunities. Kyiv: Ukraine. URL: https://legalifeukraine.com/ru/sexwork/dekriminalizacziya-seks-raboty-v-ukraine-analiz-obshhestvennogo-mneniya-oczenka-prepyatstvij-i-vozmozhnostej-3380/ [in Russian]

  20. 38% of Ukrainians support the legalization of prostitution. (2002). Korrespondent.net. URL: https://ua.korrespondent.net/ukraine/239764-za-legalizaciyu-prostituciyi-vistupae-38-ukrayinciv [in Ukrainian]

  21. Radutnyi, O.E. (2016). Information support for the prostitution legalization and decriminalization of certain related activities. Informatsiia i pravo – 2 (17), 147-157. URL: http://ippi.org.ua/sites/default/files/19_0.pdf [in Ukrainian]

Full text