The assessment of implementation level of e-learning in Ukrainian higher educational institutions by analyzing their web-resources: theoretical aspects of sociological analysis


The article dwells upon the review of the theoretical and conceptual bases of e-learning implementation analysis in Ukrainian universities, which acquires relevance in conditions of impetuous development of information and communication technologies. An intensification of informatization, digitalization and individualization trends of the educational process actualize the need to study the readiness of higher educational institutions to use and popularize electronic educational resources, methods and technologies.

Ukrainian universities start to follow the e-learning strategy considering these trends. However, they are at different levels of implementation, which is the subject of the further research. Accordingly, the purpose of the article was to identify the implementation degree of e-learning elements in Ukrainian higher educational institutions (universities, academies, institutes), what was realized through conducting the content analysis of the information that was published on the official universities’ websites. The theoretical and methodological foundations of the study of e-learning and analysis of the institutional degree and its introduction in Ukraine were considered in the first part of the article. The article expounds a phased description of the chosen methodology and the barriers faced by the research group in the study of the declared problems.

The justification of the criteria that served as the basis for the classification of Ukrainian universities was given a particular attention. General indicators for an independent assessment were developed that allowed us to avoid a subjectivity, predictable assessment and to identify the real situation of readiness of Ukrainian universities to introduce distance learning elements.

According to study results, the classification of Ukrainian universities by the implementation degree of e-learning was developed: 1) universities which follow the traditional model of education; 2) universities that combine traditional education with e-learning elements or fragmentary web-provision of an educational process; 3) universities that use web-communication support of the educational process or experimental form of e-learning; 4) universities that have an all-sufficient form of e-learning.

  1. Zhulkevska, V.O. (2004). Distance learning: the historical aspect of foreign experience. Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu – Journal of Lviv University, 18, 81-88 [in Ukrainian]

  2. Vashhuk, F.G. (Ed.). (2011). Integration into the European educational space: achievements, problems, perspectives: monograph. Uzhgorod: ZakDU [in Ukrainian]

  3. Astakhova, V. (2011). Some questions of theory and practice of continuing education. Gumanitarnye nauki – Humanitarian sciences, 3, 86-92 [in Russian]

  4. Astakhova, K. (2010). University lecturer in the transition society to an innovative economy: the vectors of change. Vishcha shkola – Tertiary school, 2, 41-47 [in Ukrainian]

  5. Bakіrov, V. (2009). Modern higher education as a subject of sociological reflection. Vіsnyk Kharkіvskoho natsіonalnoho unіversytetu іmenі V.N. Karazіna. Serіia: Sotsіolohіia v situatsіi sotsіalnykh nevyznachenostei – Bulletin of the V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Series: Sociology in situations of social ambiguities, 881, 31-36 [in Ukrainian]

  6. Astakhova, V. (Ed.). (2008). Global problems of mankind as a factor for transformation of educational systems. Kharkov: Izd-vo NUA [in Russian]

  7. Sokuryanskaya, L. (2015). The value significance of education as a factor for its modernization. In V. Bakirov (Ed.), Sociocultural barriers of modernization of the higher school of Ukraine (pp. 65-88). Kharkov: V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University [in Russian]

  8. Khizhnyak, L. (2013). The idea of online education and traps on the way to its realization. Vіsnyk Kharkіvskoho natsіonalnoho unіversytetu іmenі V.N. Karazіna. Serіia: Sotsіolohіchnі doslіdzhennia suchasnoho suspіlstva: metodolohіia, teorіia, metody – Bulletin of the V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Series: Sociological research of modern society: methodology, theory and methods, 1053, 157-161 [in Russian]

  9. Shchudlo, S. (2012). Higher education in search for quality: quo vadis. Kharkіv–Drohobych: Kolo [in Ukrainian]

  10. Lokshyna, O. (2007). Development of competence approach in education of the European Union. Shliah osvity – The way of education, 4, 15-27 [in Ukrainian]

  11. Olijnyk, V. (2001). Distance learning abroad and in Ukraine: A concise analytical review. Kyiv: CIPPO [in Ukrainian]

  12. Tanas, M., Bednarek, Ju. (2003). Online education in the new concept of didactics. Problemy osvity – The problems of education, 31, 294-302 [in Ukrainian]

  13. Vitkin, L., Borysenko, Z., Gluhova, O., Karandajev, K. (2012). Evolution of the quality management system of higher education. Standartyzatsiia, sertyfikatsiia, yakist – Standardization, certification, quality, 3, 40-45 [in Ukrainian]

  14. Dudar, Z., Revenchuk, I. (2012). The quality of distance learning: problems and solutions. Electronic media and distance learning technologies for lifelong education: Abstracts of the 8th International scientific-technical conference, 15-16 November 2012. Sumy: SumDU [in Ukrainian]

  15. Myrutenko, L. (2016). The system of assessing the quality of distance learning in Ukraine: key issues and problems. Systemy obrobky informatsii – Information processing systems, 3 (140), 260-263 [in Ukrainian]

  16. Mulina, N. (2009). Quality management of distance learning in Ukrainian university. Pedahohichna nauka: istoriia, teoriia, praktyka, tendentsii rozvytku – Teaching Science: History, Theory, Practice, Trends, 1. URL: science_arhiv_pn_n1_2009_st_19/ [in Ukrainian]

  17. Murashko, M., Nazarko, S. (2010). Formation of the evaluation model quality in higher education and the possibility of implementing the system of training. Visnyk Chernihivskoho derzhavnoho tehnolohichnoho universytetu. Seriia: Ekonomichni nauky – Journal of Chernihiv State Technological University. A series of Economics, 43 [in Ukrainian]

  18. Nozdrina, L. Study results of e-learning projects in Ukrainian schools. High society. URL: [in Ukrainian]

  19. Bakirov, V.S., Subbota, M.N. (2015). Socio-cultural conditionality of modernization of higher education. In V.S. Bakirov (Ed.), Sociocultural barriers to the modernization of higher education in Ukraine. Kharkiv: V.N. Karazin National University [in Russian]

  20. Kravchenko, A.S. (2016). E-learning in conditions of internationalization of higher education. Sotsialni tekhnolohii: aktualni problemy teorii ta praktyky – Social technologies: topical problems of theory and practice, 72, 94-100 [in Ukrainian]

  21. Khizhnyak, L.M., Khizhnyak, K.V. (2016). Hybridization in higher education in conditions of implementation of e-learning technologies. Sotsialni tekhnolohii: aktualni problemy teorii ta praktyky – Social technologies: topical problems of theory and practice, 72, 137-144 [in Ukrainian]

  22. Folomieiev, M.A., Kryzhanivska, V.I., Zhovnir, A.O., Trempolets, D.M. (2016). The readiness of Ukrainian universities to introduce e-learning (the results of the analysis of universities’ websites). In V.S. Bakirov (Ed.), Problems of introduction of e-learning technologies in Ukrainian high school: SRW report (final). Kharkiv: V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University [in Ukrainian]

  23. Kryzhanivska, V. (2016). The peculiarities of implementation of e-learning technologies in the higher education insitutions of Ukraine. Sotsialni tekhnolohii: aktualni problemy teorii ta praktyky – Social technologies: topical problems of theory and practice, 69-70, 205-215 [in Ukrainian]

  24. Concept of distance education development in Ukraine. URL: [in Ukrainian]

  25. Distance learning. Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine [in Ukrainian]

  26. Center for Distance Learning in the Ukrainian universities. URL: [in Ukrainian]

  27. IS Competition, admission campaign 2016. URL: [in Ukrainian]

  28. Ranking Web of University. URL:

Full text